


Elisha Phelps Butler's father was John Butler, he married Susan Elizabeth Hutzler on April 8th 1834 in Winchester VA. John Butler was born in 1803 in White Hall Virginia. John and Susan had 8 children.
John Thomas Butler Dec 28, 1837 - May 5, 1879
Sarah Jane Butler July 20, 1838 -Nov 8, 1868
William Hamilton Butler Oct 3, 1840 - Sept 19, 1910
Charles Wesley Butler Jan 18,1844 - Oct 21,1926
Elisha Phelps Butler (my great grandfather) Sept 14, 1846 - Jan 16, 1905
Ebenezer Coe Butler June 9, 1849 - Feb. 3, 1932
Mary Alice Butler June 1, 1852 - Oct 30,1884
Cynthia Ann Butler Pine Jan 27, 1855 - April 2, 1898
Ebenezer Coe Butler married Elizabeth Shroades on Feb 9, 1898 in Martinsburg WV. I am not sure yet how many children they had, but they had a daughter named Hester that died in infancy in either 1902 or 1904 and a daughter named Edna. Ebenezer died of Chronic Interstitial Nephritis.
William Hamilton Butler married Caroline Mason on April 4, 1876. Again, I am not sure how many children they had, but they had a daughter named Lottie that died on March 8, 1894 of a lumbar abcess at the age of 14.
Cynthia Ann Butler married Robert H. Pine on April 18, 1878, I don't know yet whether thay had any children or not. She died of Pulmonary Congestion.
Charles Wesley Butler married Dora Ann McDonald on March 30, 1869, So far I only know of 2 children that they had, Madewell Stewart Butler (born Dec 1, 1877 -- died on Sept 23, 1964 of malnutrition and anemia), and Marion Coe Butler (born Jan. 22, 1888 -- died Nov. 1, 1967 in Monongalia County WV).
The pictures are, Ebenezer Butler ( left ), Ebenezer's daughter Edna (top right), and the only known photo of Susan Elizabeth Hutzler Butler (lower right).